Draws soon and often, designs for access and equity.
ServiceBlueprintPage.001.jpeg

Service Design Blueprints

Service Design: A look inside Washington DC’s interagency experiences

DCOrgChart.png

Service Design Blueprints

Service Design: A look inside Washington DC’s interagency experiences 

Read the Case Study on Medium

Context- Aid the City Administrator of Washington DC in a multi-year exploratory study and service redesign initiative

Timeframe- 17 days

Role- Co-Designer/Researcher in two person team

Methods- Interviews, Screener Surveys, Research

Audience-Human Services Agencies: the Office of Disability Rights, the Department of Human Services and the Department of Aging and Community Living

Objectives- What are the biggest challenges and opportunities for employees serving at internal/resident facing agencies of the District of Columbia? How might these be redesigned using service blueprints to improve employee satisfaction and resident experiences indirectly?

Outcomes: Photos, Transcripts/Quotes, Survey Responses, Trends, User Insights, Challenges

Artifacts-Research Plan, Survey/Responses, Interview Script Questions and Responses, Insights and Synthesis

Deliverables-User Personas, Customer Journey Maps, Service Blueprint and Recommendations

Interviews- Over three days, my partner and I conducted 16 interviews.

We spoke to those serving at the highest levels of leadership of the Health and Human Services Cluster to understand their experiences working with the following seven key internal facing agencies:

  • Department of General Services

  • Office of the Chief Technology Officer

  • Office of Contracting and Procurement

  • Department of Human Resources

  • Office of Risk Management

  • Office of Disability Rights

  • Office of Labor Relations and Collective Bargaining

    We asked each interviewee to describe their role within the agency and:

  • What they liked about, found frustrating with and suggested improvements for, each of the above seven agencies

  • Lastly, we conducted a client sourced questionnaire which required the interviewee to card sort for each agency, the pillars of customer service, from strength to weakness.

Secondary Research using survey of residents

In order to see the entire service ecosystem including the residents’ experience, we asked our interviewees for their insight into the challenges that DC residents face when obtaining services through our local government agencies. We supplemented this with an independent survey of residents focused on experiences with the Department of Human Services. Our primary goal was to see if residents felt they had accomplished their intended tasks when obtaining services and what obstacles they encountered. The survey was disseminated across social media platforms and using Reddit.

Synthesis using Topic and Affinity Mapping

These overarching categories emerged:

Customer Service

Outreach/Awareness

Guidance/ Training

Hiring/Staffing

Tools/Technology

Topic Mapping

Topic Mapping

Affinity Mapping

Affinity Mapping

We have a good relationship when it comes to assisting employees to get reasonable accommodations for their jobs.
— DC Gov. Employee
They have a very dedicated staff who care and want to help
— DC Gov. Employee
Recruitment has been frustrating.
— DC Gov. Employee
I get scolded all the time by them and it is to the point that I am numb.
— DC Gov. Employee

User Personas, Use Cases, Customer Journey Maps

Meet Tina who is an upper level manager for a resident facing agency. Her Use Case delineates her experience making a new hire and some of the challenges she encounters along the way.

Many of these challenges also negatively impact the person who is being hired. This journey forms the center of the Service Blueprint that follows which includes Tina as the hiring manager and Mary, a soon to be new employee for the agency.

User Persona for Tina M., Upper Level Manager within a resident facing agency of the District of Columbia

User Persona for Tina M., Upper Level Manager within a resident facing agency of the District of Columbia

Tina’s Journey hiring for a new position within her organization

Tina’s Journey hiring for a new position within her organization

Service Blueprint for hiring with pain points indicated by red stars

Service Blueprint for hiring with pain points indicated by red stars

Key Take-Aways

The user values responsiveness, guidance, training and accountability.

They aim to model these behaviors therefore, the expectation is extended to from their interagency experiences.

When recruitment, screening, on-boarding and retention have identifiable pain points, our user experiences frustration and a diminished hopefulness around their work. This example highlights a few of the challenges that we heard during our interviews.

Summary

Card sorting surveys around customer service pointed consistently to a belief that courteousness is the greatest strength of each Internal Service Agency. Above else, people value people and that is hopeful! There was visible satisfaction, near I say joy, when people described a reliable and effective relationship with another agency contact.

Our recommendations to the City Administrator are to examine these processes: recruitment, hiring, staffing, training, guidance, outreach/awareness. We recommend a parallel foray in the development of customer service as a value and guiding principal.

Read the Case Study on Medium